Abstract
Background: Approximately one-third of refugees worldwide live in refugee camps. Selected neurologic diseases are actively reported in some refugee camps.
Methods: The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees monitors health visits in refugee camps with the assistance of more than 25 partner organizations using standardized case definitions. Neurologic diseases were selected and searched for the years 2008 to 2011. The number of health care visits for a neurologic disease was calculated and divided by the aggregated number of reporting months available for each refugee camp (“visits per camp-month”).
Results: Five neurologic diseases were reported from 127 refugee camps in 19 countries. Visits for chronic, noncommunicable diseases including epilepsy (53,941 visits in 1,426 camp-months, 48% female) and cerebrovascular disease (4,028 visits in 1,333 camp-months, 51% female) far exceeded those for neurologic infectious diseases (acute flaccid paralysis/poliomyelitis, 78 visits in 3,816 camp-months, 42% female; leprosy, 74 visits in 3,816 camp-months, 66% female; meningitis, 477 visits in 3,816 camp-months, 51% female). In 2011, these diseases accounted for 31,349 visits globally with 91% of visits for epilepsy.
Conclusions: Targeted programs addressing epilepsy and stroke among refugees in camps should become a priority and indicate that other chronic neurologic diseases that may be under- or misdiagnosed may also be common in refugee camps. Given that significant under-reporting is likely, our findings demonstrate the pressing need for coordinated preventive and interventional measures for epilepsy and stroke in refugee camps.
GLOSSARY
- UNHCR=
- United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees;
- webHIS=
- Web-based Health Information System
Approximately 30% of refugees lived in refugee camps in 2010, including 52% of children and 49% of women.1 Refugee camps are meant to be temporary locations for shelter and emergency aid provision, usually established by governments or international agencies in response to natural disaster, famine, political discord, or armed conflict. Although not recognized as a durable solution, refugee camps may be the home of entire generations of refugees and reach populations of more than 100,000 people per camp.1
Limited information is available on neurologic diseases in refugee camps, and is mainly focused on meningococcal meningitis outbreaks during the 1990s.2,–,5 Compiled surveillance data would be valuable for setting health care policy related to the prevention, management, and reduction of neurologic diseases in refugee camps on a global basis. Here, we present the burden of health care visits per reportable neurologic disease by country level from refugee camps supported by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).
METHODS
Data reporting and collection.
The UNHCR Web-based Health Information System (webHIS) is a standardized reporting tool designed to monitor the health status of refugees and other persons of concern to the UNHCR. Selected reportable diseases are monitored when they have the potential to affect refugees in high numbers or lead to important interventions. Data are collected at each camp by UNHCR employees and other aid workers on a weekly basis, involving 25 implementing organizations worldwide, using case definitions (table 1). Approximately 1.6 million displaced persons are covered by camps participating in the webHIS. Visit data are collected via a standardized online reporting form, downloaded at the refugee camp site, and deposited electronically each month. Not all refugee camps report on all reportable neurologic diseases every month. For each month, the number of camps reporting on the disease of interest was calculated. The tallies were then summed over months and used to standardize the reporting counts of specific diseases, yielding per camp-month visit rates. This standardization allowed counts to be compared across various strata (e.g., sex, reporting years).
Overview of reportable neurologic disease visits to the UNHCR (2008–2011)
For each health visit, patient sex, location, and month of encounter were reported. Neurologic diseases were searched among all reportable diseases in webHIS during the study timeframe (January 1, 2008–December 31, 2011 for acute flaccid paralysis, leprosy, and meningitis; July 1, 2009–December 31, 2011 for cerebrovascular disease and epilepsy). Camp level information is available at https://unhcr.org/his. Use of deidentified programmatic data used in this study was approved by The Johns Hopkins University Institutional Review Board.
RESULTS
Participating countries were from 3 World Health Organization–defined regions: African (93 refugee camps in 13 countries: Burundi, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia, Guinea, Kenya, Namibia, Rwanda, Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia), Eastern Mediterranean (14 refugee camps in 3 countries: Djibouti, Sudan, Yemen), and Southeast Asian (20 camps in 3 countries: Bangladesh, Nepal, Thailand). The countries with the highest number of reporting camps were Chad (n = 28), Ethiopia (n = 13), Uganda (n = 11), Sudan (n = 10), and Cameroon (n = 10). Reporting of epilepsy and cerebrovascular disease began in July 2009 and was available in 14 countries for cerebrovascular diseases and 16 countries for epilepsy (table 2).
Location and burden of neurologic disease visits by country for refugee camps reporting to UNHCR webHIS (2008–2011)
There were 5 reported neurologic diseases in the webHIS of the UNHCR. In 2011, these diseases accounted for 31,349 visits globally of which 91% were for epilepsy. The age distribution of the 53,941 health visits for epilepsy for all years reported was as follows: <5 years old (n = 3,964 visits, 7.3%), 5–17 years old (n = 22,736 visits, 42.1%), 18–59 years old (n = 22,489 visits, 41.7%), and >60 years old (n = 719 visits, 1.3%). Age information was unavailable for 4,038 visits (7.5%). Table 1 compares the reported health visit utilization of neurologic disease, standardized by number of reporting months available.
DISCUSSION
The UNHCR webHIS demonstrates feasibility of an active reporting system for key neurologic diseases in refugee camps on a global basis. WebHIS depends on the skills of nonphysician health care workers to report on neurologic diseases to monitor disease outbreaks, reveal health utilization trends, and develop broad estimates of the burden of disease. To date, most reported neurologic diseases of interest to UNHCR have been infectious in nature. However, these results suggest that infectious neurologic diseases are much less common than epilepsy and stroke.
The recent inclusion of stroke and epilepsy on reporting forms will be crucial for future humanitarian crises. Epilepsy represents more than 9 out of every 10 visits for reportable neurologic diseases in refugee camps. The underlying causes of epilepsy and seizures in refugee camps are unknown, but likely represent similar risk factors to other inhabitants in the same region, including perinatal injury and birth defects, febrile seizures, head trauma, genetic diseases, cerebral malaria, previous stroke, and related causes. The overall aging population and existence of affordable medications on the WHO Essential List of Medicines should lead to more precise and field-tested case definitions for neurologic diseases among refugees in camps, including studies focusing on different age groups. It is not reported whether cases were treated or untreated. If, however, each health visit for epilepsy represented one individual who required antiepileptic drug treatment, the cost of phenobarbital to treat all refugees would be relatively small. Given a median defined daily dose of phenobarbital of 100 mg, the cost to treat all refugees with epilepsy in camps would be approximately $270,000 USD (estimated approximately $5 USD per person per year).
Monitoring of meningitis in sub-Saharan Africa is an important way to avoid epidemic outbreaks due to Neisseria meningitidis. Although likely under-reported here, the overall low counts of meningitis should be considered as a success of surveillance, treatment, and recent vaccination campaigns. In Goma, Democratic Republic of Congo (former Zaire) in 1994, recovery rates from meningococcal meningitis treated with IV penicillin and chloramphenicol in a field hospital were comparable to rates found in advanced medical facilities.2 Early vaccination against meningococcal meningitis in a refugee camp of Sudanese nationals in northern Uganda led to less deaths compared to a camp where vaccination was delayed.3 Simple, reliable surveillance systems for meningitis have been advocated for more than 20 years4; however, even when implemented, important infectious disease outbreaks can be missed. The eventual inclusion of dementia, traumatic head and spinal cord injury, cerebral palsy, and chronic pain will also be important in the surveillance of neurologic diseases in future humanitarian crisis settings; this will require further training of medical staff on diagnosis and treatment.
We recognize important limitations to reporting data from the webHIS. Data are reported for each visit rather than for each refugee. The population structure of refugee camps is not static. Therefore, incidence and prevalence estimates of disease by country and camp level cannot be made. Data were entered based on standard case definitions and were not verified by physicians in many cases. Cases of meningitis were unlikely to have had routine CSF confirmation, and others may not have reached medical attention. Cerebral malaria and multiple other neurologic diseases of importance to refugees may not be reported because of a lack of training and limited monitoring of implementation of individual reporting categories. Therefore, it is assumed that there is significant under-reporting and risk of misclassification of most neurologic diseases.
However, given the available evidence, there is a growing need for guidelines for the prevention, evaluation, and care of refugees with neurologic diseases. This includes better coordination of information and action through roll-out programs for aspirin, antihypertensive medications, phenobarbital, phenytoin, analgesics, and potentially other antiepileptic drugs and levodopa. Since refugee camps often have better reporting capacity and treatment availability than for populations in the host country, attention to the neurologic health of refugees can advance care in the larger geographic regions where camps exist.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
Dr. Mateen was involved with data interpretation, data analysis, writing, and editing of the manuscript. Dr. Carone was involved with data interpretation, data analysis, writing, and editing of the manuscript. Dr. Haskew was involved with data acquisition, data interpretation, and editing of the manuscript. Dr. Spiegel was involved with data acquisition, data interpretation, and editing of the manuscript.
DISCLOSURE
The authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscript. Go to Neurology.org for full disclosures.
Footnotes
Study funding: Dr. Mateen is supported by the American Academy of Neurology Practice Research Fellowship Grant.
- Copyright © 2012 by AAN Enterprises, Inc.
Disputes & Debates: Rapid online correspondence
REQUIREMENTS
If you are uploading a letter concerning an article:
You must have updated your disclosures within six months: http://submit.neurology.org
Your co-authors must send a completed Publishing Agreement Form to Neurology Staff (not necessary for the lead/corresponding author as the form below will suffice) before you upload your comment.
If you are responding to a comment that was written about an article you originally authored:
You (and co-authors) do not need to fill out forms or check disclosures as author forms are still valid
and apply to letter.
Submission specifications:
- Submissions must be < 200 words with < 5 references. Reference 1 must be the article on which you are commenting.
- Submissions should not have more than 5 authors. (Exception: original author replies can include all original authors of the article)
- Submit only on articles published within 6 months of issue date.
- Do not be redundant. Read any comments already posted on the article prior to submission.
- Submitted comments are subject to editing and editor review prior to posting.